Charter School Vulnerability
by Craig Branch
Charter Schools as a new concept are attractive in many ways but are
also presenting some significant liabilities. "Charter schools are public
schools formed by a group of citizens, frequently public school teachers
and administrators who feel they can run a better public school if they
had fewer strings attached, who obtain a charter from the state.
"They are exempt from [many] state laws and regulations which apply
to other public schools, but are funded on a per-pupil basis like other
public schools," (Guide to the Issues 1996, Alabama Family Alliance, p.
5).
In other words, charter schools can offer an alternative to regular
public schools if teachers and parents desire unique or alternative teaching
approaches or philosophies. Although they have much latitude, they still
must be free from any sectarian religious influence.
The latitude on alternative approaches and teacher qualifications has
opened the door for some groups with specific religious philosophies to
disguise their motives in such a way as to gain entrance into the charter
school arena.
Certain New Age-oriented
Montessori schools have become Charter schools. In addition to Sacramento's
Waldorf school (see "Waldorf. Controversy", p. 5) and Scientology's Applied
Scholastics (see "Applied Scientology.", p.15), Waldorf schools have opened
in San Diego, Novato, Nevada City, Maryville, and Sabastopal (all in California),
Boulder, Flagstaff, Detroit, Milwaukee, New York City. Many others are
proposed.
Dr. Stephen Yulish, formerly a New Age devotee, wrote his master's thesis
on the educational philosophy of Waldorf's founder, Rudolph Steiner, for
the University of Illinois. Dr. Yulish taught History of American Education
at the University of Arizona from 1975-1982 and later became a Christian.
Upon encountering the Waldorf Pine Forest Charter school in his hometown
of Flagstaff, he challenged both the constitutionality and educational
soundness of the program. Unfortunately, after running into the typical
governmental red tape, and not being able to gain the interest and activism
of the churches in the community, Dr. Yulish gave up the fight.
This must not happen. Christians must be aware that they have both a
cultural and a personal mandate. They are whenever possible, within the
law, to tear down every speculative philosophy erected against the truth
of Christ (2 Corinthians
10:3-5). They are, in this regard, their "brother's keepers."
If a system is illegal or unjust Christians must become activists and
use all of their positions of influence to move those in authority to do
the right thing. Of course this activism must always involve prayer to
the One who holds the heart of the king in His hand and moves it wherever
He wills (Proverbs. 21:1).
Watchman Fellowship's Alabama office took this mandate seriously and
began to work with many other Christians and like minded people to eliminate
New Age influences being smuggled into Alabama schools. The result, after
much research, prayer and activism, was that Alabama's State Board of Education
and Legislative committee passed a regulation/law that prohibits those
techniques in the public schools.
|